Carriers & Claims Allstate All Claims: 800-255-7828 AmTrust All Claims: 888-887-3062 Auto-Owners Insurance All Claims: 888-252-4626 Glass Claims: 800-264-4143 Roadside Assistance: 888-869-2642 Builders Insurance Group All Claims: 800-883-9305 Builders Mutual Insurance Company All Claims: 800-809-4862 Cincinnati Insurance Companies All Claims: 877-242-2544 CNA Surety All Claims: 877-672-6115 Encompass All Claims: 800-588-7400 Frankenmuth All Claims: 800-234-4433 Foremost Insurance Group All Claims: 800-527-3907 Grange Insurance All Claims: 800-445-3030 Glass Claims: 800-835-2257 Hagerty All Claims: 800-922-4050 Liberty Mutual Insurance All Claims: 1-800-225-2467 National General All Claims: 800-325-1088 Nationwide All Claims: 800-282-1446 Progressive All Claims: 800-274-4499 Safeco Insurance All Claims: 800-332-3226 US Assure All Claims: 800-987-3373